Friday, April 15, 2022

The Public Transcripts 20 Lord Goldsmith and the syntax of 1441...

Lord Goldsmith infamously, we learnt with hindsight, changed his mind from "it isn't legal" to "it is legal" as the date of the invasion approached.  His explanations for this are extremely long winded (you dont get to be Attorney General by using one word when a thousand will do).  But it comes down to something like this...


...after analysing the syntax of resolution 1441 he decided that a case could be made that it implicitly sanctioned the use of force even though it clearly didn't say that explicitly.  From this point he decided that it would be wrong to view the document "in a vacuum" and that the context and meaning intended by the Security Council members should be considered.

No comments:

Post a Comment

The Private Transcripts MI6 - SIS2 Part 2 - Alastair Campbell the “unguided missile”

  More redaction before Sir Lawrence Freedman asserts that after UNSCOM withdrew from Iraq in the late 90s MI6 lost most of its sources.. . ...